Ocular Motor Findings Aid in Differentiation of Spinocerebellar Ataxia Type 17 from Huntington's Disease

Abstract

Differentiation of spinocerebellar ataxia type 17 (SCA17) from Huntington's disease (HD) is often challenging since they share the clinical features of chorea, parkinsonism, and dystonia. The ocular motor findings remain to be elucidated in SCA17, and may help differentiating SCA17 from HD. We retrospectively compared the ocular motor findings of 11 patients with SCA17 with those of 10 patients with HD. In SCA17, abnormal ocular motor findings included impaired smooth pursuit (9/11, 82%), dysmetric saccades (9/11, 82%), central positional nystagmus (CPN, 7/11, 64%), abnormal head-impulse tests (4/11, 36%), and horizontal gaze-evoked nystagmus (GEN, 3/11, 27%). Among these, CPN was more frequently observed in SCA17 than in HD (7/11 (64%) vs. 0/10 (0%), p = 0.004) while saccadic slowing was more frequently observed in HD than in SCA17 (8/10 (80%) vs. 2/11 (18%), p = 0.009). Of six patients with follow-up evaluation, five later developed bilateral saccadic hypermetria (n = 4), GEN (n = 1), CPN (n = 1), bilaterally abnormal smooth pursuit (n = 1), and hyperactive head-impulse responses (n = 1) along with a clinical decline. Ocular motor abnormalities can be utilized as a diagnostic marker for differentiation of SCA17 from HD as well as a surrogate marker for clinical decline in SCA17.